Were I Not a Girl: The Inspiring and True Story of Dr. James Barry

by Lisa Robinson (Author) Lauren Simkin Berke (Illustrator)

Reading Level: 2nd − 3rd Grade

This unique picture book biography tells the story of Dr. James Barry, born female, who lived as a man from age 18 to his death.

Like other girls of her time, Margaret Bulkley didn't go to school. She wouldn't grow up to own property, be a soldier, a doctor, or hold any job other than perhaps maid or governor--such was a girl's lot in 19th century England. And was she comfortable born in a girl's body? We will never know. What we do know is that at the age of 18, she tugged off her stockings and dress, cut her red-gold curls, and vanished. In her place appeared a young man. Margaret became James Barry. James would attend medical school, become a doctor and a soldier, travel the world. He would fall in love, deliver babies, and fight in a duel. And he would live a rich full life.

Here is a picure book that is both a fascinating and sensitively drawn portrait of someone who would not be undervalued, and an important introduction to the concept of gender identity.

Select format:
Hardcover
$17.99

School Library Journal

K-Gr 4--This accessible picture book biography spotlights a lesser-known part of LGBTQ+ history. Dr. James Barry, a white transgender man, accomplished great feats. He was Inspector General of Hospitals for the British Army, performed the first documented Cesarean section in which both the mother and baby survived, and advocated for better health-care conditions for disadvantaged patients. Robinson, who is also a therapist, presents the facts in a conversational tone. Readers are addressed directly; the text alerts them to the gaps in what is known about Barry's life. The process of Barry's transitioning is written in a straightforward manner, switching from "she" to "he" pronouns. The majority of the narrative focuses on his remarkable achievements as a surgeon. Simkin Berke's pencil and watercolor illustrations feel appropriately historic, with expertly sketched British architecture and ornately framed portraits of Barry. The artwork uses a style reminiscent of Barbara McClintock's picture book biographies. Barry is portrayed as red-haired and fashionable. Back matter expands on the details of Barry's personal and professional life and includes notes about transitioning and people who identify as transgender (though this word is not used within the narrative). VERDICT Recommended for biography collections, especially those looking to include more books that cover LGBTQ+ history.--Clara Hendricks, Cambridge P.L., MA

Copyright 2020 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

Review quotes

"Recommended for biography collections, especially those looking to include more books that cover LGBTQ+ history." —School Library Journal

"A remarkable life is given a sensitive portrayal in this picture-book biography." —The Horn Book
Lisa Robinson
Lisa Robinson is the author of several picture books, including Pirates Don't Go to Kindergarten!, a GoodReads Choice nominee; The Sweetest Scoop: Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream Revolution, and Were I Not A Girl: The Inspiring Story Of Dr. James Barry. She holds an MFA in Creative Writing for Young People from Lesley University. Lisa lives with her family and cats in the Boston area, where she and her daughters enjoy practicing aerial silks at their local circus studio.

Hadley Hooper is a painter and illustrator whose artwork has been exhibited in galleries and museums in major cities such as San Francisco, Toronto, New York, Denver, and Santa Fe. As a picture book illustrator, she has worked with bestselling authors such as Patricia Maclachlan, Liz Garton Scanlon, and Jan Greenberg. She lives in Denver with her partner Hugh Graham, and their dog Augie.
Classification
Non-fiction
ISBN-13
9781984849052
Lexile Measure
780
Guided Reading Level
-
Publisher
Schwartz & Wade Books
Publication date
October 20, 2020
Series
-
BISAC categories
JNF007020 - Juvenile Nonfiction | Biography & Autobiography | Historical
JNF053080 - Juvenile Nonfiction | LGBT
JNF013110 - Juvenile Nonfiction | Concepts | Body
Library of Congress categories
Great Britain
Biographies
England
Women physicians
Gender nonconformity
Surgeons
Male impersonators
Barry, James

Subscribe to our delicious e-newsletter!